Login  
Forgot Password?

Welcome to the Studentawards Forum!

The Studentawards Forum is a virtual community where students, educators, and parents gather to share their knowledge, insights, issues, and ideas.

Feel free to take a look around and jump in on the conversation.  If you’re new to this website, you will have to SIGN UP to submit a post.

Questions? Our Forum FAQ and Forum Rules can help. 

Happy Postings!

12 Pages 123>»
3rd year Canadian medical student happy to answer questions! Options
DrJay
#1 Posted : Thursday, May 03, 2012 10:19:28 PM
Rank: Senior Student


Joined: 5/3/2012
Posts: 93
UPDATE July 11, 2012:

My name is Josh, some of you might know me as the guy who started MedHopeful. For those of you who don't know me, I am currently a 3rd year Medical Student at UofT and I have run a blog called MedHopeful for almost 4 years now which provides stories and advice relating to undergrad, scholarships and medical school.

I originally wanted to remain anonymous in this thread because I was working on a few new projects (like a new group blog I had started) with some medical school classmates who wanted to remain anonymous. However, after long discussions and thinking, I decided to go back to primarily posting on MedHopeful. I also figured that I was OK not being anonymous (my friends still want to be, which is fine and I understand why).

In any case, I am happy to answer any questions, and for those of you who didn't know, I started a similar thread like this last year on the old Student Awards forums, which you might also find useful:

http://forums.studentawa...nto-Medical-School.aspx

* * * * *

Hey everyone,

I am a 3rd year medical student at a Canadian medical school. My first 2 years were spent mostly in the classroom learning anatomy, physiology, disease, treatments, etc.

I started 3rd year in September 2011, and since then, I have been in "clerkship" - which means I have been working and learning full time in the hospital - seeing real patients everyday, and learning to diagnose/treat their illnesses. I have to say, it's very different from what I imagined. No matter how much you try to learn what it's like to practice medicine (e.g. shadowing), you really don't know what it's like until you do it.

I found these forums very helpful while studying in undergrad and applying to medical school. I'd like to give back by answering questions about medical school if anyone has any.

I'll try to be as honest as possible. I just won't be revealing any personal details as I'd prefer to remain anonymous.

Ask away! :)

P.S. I now blog everyday about med school life, getting in to med school, undergrad tips, etc. (see signature)
TD Canada Trust Scholar 2006
University of Toronto M.D. Candidate, Class of 2013

MedHopeful.com - my blog with advice and entertainment on undergrad, scholarships and medical school.

Get Started - an introductory guide for premeds to learn about applying to medical school.

Mac Health Sci Application Guide - my advice for the McMaster Health Sciences supplementary application.

EssaySensei.ca - where I provide 1-on-1 essay help for applications to medical school, scholarships, awards and programs.
happygleek
#2 Posted : Thursday, May 03, 2012 11:21:18 PM
Rank: Frosh


Joined: 3/6/2011
Posts: 49
That's super great that we have someone like yourself to answer our questions!

What was your undergrad degree? Also, are there any past nursing student/nurses in your program?
DrJay
#3 Posted : Thursday, May 03, 2012 11:29:46 PM
Rank: Senior Student


Joined: 5/3/2012
Posts: 93
happygleek wrote:
That's super great that we have someone like yourself to answer our questions!

What was your undergrad degree? Also, are there any past nursing student/nurses in your program?


thanks! :)

My undergrad degree was in the life sciences, specifically biology.

Absolutely, there are past nurses/nursing students in my program. Med students come from many diverse backgrounds. While it's true that many med students come from a life science background, there are also many who have done very different things, including nursing, arts, engineering, business, and many more.

I think being in nursing is actually an advantage in the med school admissions process because you already have significant health care experience, which not only helps in the med school interview (e.g. answering health care questions, talking about communication/team work experiences, etc.), but you also have a leg up when you start learning in the clinical environment with real patients.
TD Canada Trust Scholar 2006
University of Toronto M.D. Candidate, Class of 2013

MedHopeful.com - my blog with advice and entertainment on undergrad, scholarships and medical school.

Get Started - an introductory guide for premeds to learn about applying to medical school.

Mac Health Sci Application Guide - my advice for the McMaster Health Sciences supplementary application.

EssaySensei.ca - where I provide 1-on-1 essay help for applications to medical school, scholarships, awards and programs.
larissa42
#4 Posted : Thursday, May 03, 2012 11:44:05 PM
Rank: Frosh


Joined: 12/7/2011
Posts: 21
I have a few questions,

What was your university GPA?
Can you give a summary of the med school application process?
What have you found most challenging about med school so far?
Are you sleep deprived and stressed 24/7? lol

Thanks for taking the time to answer questions on this forum, im sure a lot of people will really appreciate it, myself included :)
larissa42
#5 Posted : Thursday, May 03, 2012 11:46:11 PM
Rank: Frosh


Joined: 12/7/2011
Posts: 21
oh and also what type of volunteering, jobs, research or extracurriculars did you do in your undergrad years?
DrJay
#6 Posted : Friday, May 04, 2012 12:02:22 AM
Rank: Senior Student


Joined: 5/3/2012
Posts: 93
larissa42 wrote:
I have a few questions,

What was your university GPA?
Can you give a summary of the med school application process?
What have you found most challenging about med school so far?
Are you sleep deprived and stressed 24/7? lol

Thanks for taking the time to answer questions on this forum, im sure a lot of people will really appreciate it, myself included :)


No problem! Happy to help :)

My university GPA was somewhere in the 3.9's.

I wrote a really long summary of the med school application process in a new premed website I am starting with some classmates. I don't think I'm allowed to post the link... but you should be able to find it, if you know what I mean ;)

In short, the med school application process is basically:
1. Complete at least 2 to 3 years of undergrad. Make sure you take any prerequisite courses (each med school is different). Mean while, keep up your GPA, get involved in your school and community, and take the MCAT.
2. In the Fall of your 3rd or 4th year of undergrad, you are eligible to apply to med school - this usually involves a list of your awards/activities, a personal essay of some sort, and 3 reference letters (this varies from school to school). Keep in mind that many applicants are also Masters and Phd students, as well as people in the working world who have previously completed undergrad degrees.
3. In Feb-April, med schools send out Rejections and Interview Invites. The interview is usually either a traditional style interview (1 doctor and 1 med student doing a 30-45 minute interview with you) or the Multiple Mini Interview (where you do 10 different 10-minute stations where you must discuss ethical scenarios, act, etc.).
4. In May, for applicants who were interviewed, you find out whether you were accepted, waitlisted (this means you might get in if a spot frees up) or rejected.

The most challenging part about medical school is the volume of information you are expected to know. There's a lot of memorization. I am the type of learner who is more into "understanding why", but a lot of medicine is just knowing the facts, which has been particularly challenging for me. If you don't like rote memorization, medicine can be really frustrating sometimes.

Medical school is as stressful as you want it to be for the most part. No one tells you how much to study. Some people go to the library and study everyday. Others cram days before the exam.

In terms of sleep deprivation, once you start clerkship (3rd/4th year) and are in the hospital full time, there are some days when you will be "on call" where you work 24 hour+ shifts. Depending on what department you are in, you may or may not sleep during those 24 hour shifts.

Medicine has it's pros and cons, but I don't think it's as glamorous as many people think. It's one of those jobs where you don't realize how tough it can be until you're knee deep in it. There are definitely quite a few people who end up regretting going into the profession.
TD Canada Trust Scholar 2006
University of Toronto M.D. Candidate, Class of 2013

MedHopeful.com - my blog with advice and entertainment on undergrad, scholarships and medical school.

Get Started - an introductory guide for premeds to learn about applying to medical school.

Mac Health Sci Application Guide - my advice for the McMaster Health Sciences supplementary application.

EssaySensei.ca - where I provide 1-on-1 essay help for applications to medical school, scholarships, awards and programs.
DrJay
#7 Posted : Friday, May 04, 2012 12:07:11 AM
Rank: Senior Student


Joined: 5/3/2012
Posts: 93
larissa42 wrote:
oh and also what type of volunteering, jobs, research or extracurriculars did you do in your undergrad years?


I did biology lab research in the summers for a few years, but never wrote a paper or went to a conference or anything. I was involved in things like music groups, volunteering with health facilities, social justice groups, etc.

I know everyone says it, but it's true - there isn't any magic formula to getting into med school. If you have a pretty good GPA, MCAT and ECs, and some luck, you have a pretty good chance of getting into med school, even if it takes a few tries.
TD Canada Trust Scholar 2006
University of Toronto M.D. Candidate, Class of 2013

MedHopeful.com - my blog with advice and entertainment on undergrad, scholarships and medical school.

Get Started - an introductory guide for premeds to learn about applying to medical school.

Mac Health Sci Application Guide - my advice for the McMaster Health Sciences supplementary application.

EssaySensei.ca - where I provide 1-on-1 essay help for applications to medical school, scholarships, awards and programs.
DrJay
#8 Posted : Friday, May 04, 2012 3:33:40 PM
Rank: Senior Student


Joined: 5/3/2012
Posts: 93
I just wrote this to sort of answer the common question "what ECs should you do to get into med school?" You might find this useful:

Probably the #1 question I get asked by premeds is: "What extra-curriculars did you do to get into medical school?"

Premeds ask this question for a number of reasons. For one, they want to know what works - am I doing things even remotely attractive to medical schools? And secondly, they want to know how they match up - am I doing enough?

However, I think it's a dangerous question to ask because it can mislead premeds into thinking they need to do X or Y to get into medical school.

Just to clarify for those who haven't had this question answered before: there is NO magic formula of ECs and volunteering to get you into medical school.

If I surveyed my entire medical school class, I would find a huge variety of experiences.

There are Masters and PhD graduates with publications, research conference presentations, etc. Then there arts graduates who have never done any academic research in their entire lives.

There are sports addicts, who joined every single school sports club and team. Then there are those who immersed themselves in music. Or social justice causes. Or none of the above.

The only common denominator among med students and their ECs is that they worked really hard. They realized that quality was more important than quantity.

All that said, if you could only do one EC, I would recommend that you do something in community leadership.

When I say community leadership, I'm basically saying having a leadership role in a group or club that does something positive and meaningful for your community.

Just find something you like doing and make a community leadership activity out of it. If you are interested in social justice issues, become the president of a school social justice club you believe in. If you like teaching math, go start a local tutoring group. If you fancy hockey, go coach a local kid's hockey team. And don't just do the bare minimum - make it great. Grow it. Do something aewsome.

The power of doing a community leadership activity is that it allows you to develop and demonstrate key qualities attractive to med school admissions committees:

1. Leadership - this is obvious
2. Teamwork - anyone who is a good leader should in theory be a good team player as well
3. Communication - you can't be a successful community leader if you can't communicate well
4. Commitment / good work ethic - if you are successful, you probably worked damn hard at it
5. Service - serving your fellow human being and creating positive change in your community

Not only will you have developed important skills for being a good doctor, and for being a competitive applicant, you will hopefully have invoked some meaningful, positive change in your community. It's a win, win, win situation.
TD Canada Trust Scholar 2006
University of Toronto M.D. Candidate, Class of 2013

MedHopeful.com - my blog with advice and entertainment on undergrad, scholarships and medical school.

Get Started - an introductory guide for premeds to learn about applying to medical school.

Mac Health Sci Application Guide - my advice for the McMaster Health Sciences supplementary application.

EssaySensei.ca - where I provide 1-on-1 essay help for applications to medical school, scholarships, awards and programs.
WKHC
#9 Posted : Friday, May 04, 2012 4:18:21 PM
Rank: Frosh


Joined: 4/28/2012
Posts: 27
DrJay wrote:
I just wrote this to sort of answer the common question "what ECs should you do to get into med school?" You might find this useful:

Probably the #1 question I get asked by premeds is: "What extra-curriculars did you do to get into medical school?"

Premeds ask this question for a number of reasons. For one, they want to know what works - am I doing things even remotely attractive to medical schools? And secondly, they want to know how they match up - am I doing enough?

However, I think it's a dangerous question to ask because it can mislead premeds into thinking they need to do X or Y to get into medical school.

Just to clarify for those who haven't had this question answered before: there is NO magic formula of ECs and volunteering to get you into medical school.

If I surveyed my entire medical school class, I would find a huge variety of experiences.

There are Masters and PhD graduates with publications, research conference presentations, etc. Then there arts graduates who have never done any academic research in their entire lives.

There are sports addicts, who joined every single school sports club and team. Then there are those who immersed themselves in music. Or social justice causes. Or none of the above.

The only common denominator among med students and their ECs is that they worked really hard. They realized that quality was more important than quantity.

All that said, if you could only do one EC, I would recommend that you do something in community leadership.

When I say community leadership, I'm basically saying having a leadership role in a group or club that does something positive and meaningful for your community.

Just find something you like doing and make a community leadership activity out of it. If you are interested in social justice issues, become the president of a school social justice club you believe in. If you like teaching math, go start a local tutoring group. If you fancy hockey, go coach a local kid's hockey team. And don't just do the bare minimum - make it great. Grow it. Do something aewsome.

The power of doing a community leadership activity is that it allows you to develop and demonstrate key qualities attractive to med school admissions committees:

1. Leadership - this is obvious
2. Teamwork - anyone who is a good leader should in theory be a good team player as well
3. Communication - you can't be a successful community leader if you can't communicate well
4. Commitment / good work ethic - if you are successful, you probably worked damn hard at it
5. Service - serving your fellow human being and creating positive change in your community

Not only will you have developed important skills for being a good doctor, and for being a competitive applicant, you will hopefully have invoked some meaningful, positive change in your community. It's a win, win, win situation.


Thank you so much for this! This is probably the best thread on here so far. Thanks!

Western BioMed 2016
DrJay
#10 Posted : Friday, May 04, 2012 7:59:37 PM
Rank: Senior Student


Joined: 5/3/2012
Posts: 93
WKHC wrote:
Thank you so much for this! This is probably the best thread on here so far. Thanks!


No problem! Glad you are finding it helpful :)


aquarius wrote:
A family friend's son from Dalhousie got into Western with full 4 years scholarship with just one EC and that was volunteering at the soup kitchen from the age of 9 and he also got accepted at Dalhousie and Queens.

Another medical student that I meet at Ottawa open house did his undergrad at Trent and never had a single EC because he was working to support himself .

My mom asked her client what ECs did her daughter did to get into Macmaster and she said was nothing. The daughter did her 1st year at Western then transferred to York in the hope of getting higher GPA.

My family doctor's son got full scholarship to Ottawa from UFT and his only EC is singing in the church choir.

I think ( my personal opinion) , LUCK players a bigger role in getting into a medical school than ECs.


Definitely, luck plays a big role in getting into medical school. There are always many more qualified applicants than there are spots. But that's why I think if you have a competitive application and apply enough times, most likely you will get in at some point.
TD Canada Trust Scholar 2006
University of Toronto M.D. Candidate, Class of 2013

MedHopeful.com - my blog with advice and entertainment on undergrad, scholarships and medical school.

Get Started - an introductory guide for premeds to learn about applying to medical school.

Mac Health Sci Application Guide - my advice for the McMaster Health Sciences supplementary application.

EssaySensei.ca - where I provide 1-on-1 essay help for applications to medical school, scholarships, awards and programs.
murphyDrizzle
#11 Posted : Friday, May 04, 2012 9:24:44 PM
Rank: Frosh


Joined: 5/4/2012
Posts: 12
I was really stressed and confused about this whole process so i can't tell you how happy i was to see you taking time out of your busy schedule to help us out. I know you must have your hands full with med school so I'll try to be as brief as possible.

1. Do medical schools look at what undergrad school you went to? Meaning do they prefer one over the other or does it boil down just to the marks you received?

2. Besides from getting high marks, volunteering a lot, what else can we do do increase our chances to get into medical school?

Once again, thanks alot for your help!
DrJay
#12 Posted : Friday, May 04, 2012 10:02:24 PM
Rank: Senior Student


Joined: 5/3/2012
Posts: 93
murphyDrizzle wrote:
I was really stressed and confused about this whole process so i can't tell you how happy i was to see you taking time out of your busy schedule to help us out. I know you must have your hands full with med school so I'll try to be as brief as possible.

1. Do medical schools look at what undergrad school you went to? Meaning do they prefer one over the other or does it boil down just to the marks you received?

2. Besides from getting high marks, volunteering a lot, what else can we do do increase our chances to get into medical school?

Once again, thanks alot for your help!


1. Medical schools will tell you that it doesn't matter what undergrad school or program you went to, as long as you have the necessary GPA and prerequisites.

For medical schools that use strict GPA cutoffs (e.g. University of Western Ontario), this is definitely true - it doesn't matter what school you went to.

For schools where it's not exactly clear how they use your GPA (e.g. UofT), no one except the admissions committee knows for certain. Maybe they do, maybe they don't, but I suspect it does not play a significant role. Every medical school class has students from many different universities in Canada, including the "easier" ones.

2. Getting a good MCAT is really important because every school uses it differently. For a school like UofT, all you need is a 9/9/9/N. For a school like Western, you might need a 9/10/11/Q. The point is the better you do on the MCAT, the more medical schools you are eligible for. The MCAT is a tough but important test, one that you want to take a few times as possible, so when you are studying for it, really study your hardest.

Also, I think some applicants forget how important it is to spend the time to put together a great application. You've spent the last 3+ years working your tail off to have great marks and a great resume - truly, you can spend 1-2 months working your tail off even more to turn that resume into a great essay.

Don't write your essay last minute. Really spend time thinking about which references you want to ask, and give them advanced notice. You've worked this hard already, you owe it to yourself to present the best version of yourself to the admissions committee.
TD Canada Trust Scholar 2006
University of Toronto M.D. Candidate, Class of 2013

MedHopeful.com - my blog with advice and entertainment on undergrad, scholarships and medical school.

Get Started - an introductory guide for premeds to learn about applying to medical school.

Mac Health Sci Application Guide - my advice for the McMaster Health Sciences supplementary application.

EssaySensei.ca - where I provide 1-on-1 essay help for applications to medical school, scholarships, awards and programs.
murphyDrizzle
#13 Posted : Friday, May 04, 2012 10:09:20 PM
Rank: Frosh


Joined: 5/4/2012
Posts: 12
Oh Ok that really clears up a lot of things for me. Thanks alot i appreciate it!
stordz
#14 Posted : Saturday, May 05, 2012 10:11:33 AM
Rank: Frosh




Joined: 10/23/2011
Posts: 22
I have to decide between doing an undergrad in science at Acadia, a small university, or an undergrad in chemical engineering at McGill. I'm also waiting on Mac Health Sci but I'm being realistic and expecting not to get in.

Do you know any engineers who are in medicine? I also know it is a GPA killer, which is the only reason I'm hesitant of accepting it, however should I decide not to pursue medicine it would give me a good back up.

Or would it be better to take science at a small university where I would be able to have a very high GPA and more spare time to do EC's? Thanks!
McGill University - Chemical Engineering '16
DrJay
#15 Posted : Saturday, May 05, 2012 10:40:08 PM
Rank: Senior Student


Joined: 5/3/2012
Posts: 93
stordz wrote:
I have to decide between doing an undergrad in science at Acadia, a small university, or an undergrad in chemical engineering at McGill. I'm also waiting on Mac Health Sci but I'm being realistic and expecting not to get in.

Do you know any engineers who are in medicine? I also know it is a GPA killer, which is the only reason I'm hesitant of accepting it, however should I decide not to pursue medicine it would give me a good back up.

Or would it be better to take science at a small university where I would be able to have a very high GPA and more spare time to do EC's? Thanks!


Absolutely, I have friends who studied engineering and are now in medicine. The main challenge they had was getting used to more rote memorization in medical school, as they said engineering was mostly understanding-based.

You're right it's a tough decision, in terms of how it will affect your marks. I'm not sure how different your GPA would be between engineering and science.

Talk to friends who are now in chemical engineering - how are their marks compared to their high school marks? Also, reflect on life after undergrad - if you don't get into medical school, what would you rather do? And how important is medical school? For some people it's the only career they want, for others they would rather focus on engineering, and if they get into med school great, but if not they are still OK.

It really comes down to your personal priorities, which I know is hard to figure out at this point in your life. But for sure, try and talk to others currently in engineering and see how they are finding it. If any engineering students/grads are reading this thread, input would be helpful too! :)

Best of luck.
TD Canada Trust Scholar 2006
University of Toronto M.D. Candidate, Class of 2013

MedHopeful.com - my blog with advice and entertainment on undergrad, scholarships and medical school.

Get Started - an introductory guide for premeds to learn about applying to medical school.

Mac Health Sci Application Guide - my advice for the McMaster Health Sciences supplementary application.

EssaySensei.ca - where I provide 1-on-1 essay help for applications to medical school, scholarships, awards and programs.
Bowchickawowwow
#16 Posted : Sunday, May 06, 2012 5:58:00 PM
Rank: Senior Student


Joined: 12/31/2010
Posts: 143
Thanks for taking the time to answer questions. I was wondering if you took Orgo in the summer? Also, what 2 years in Health Sci were your highest averages?
Bleeding Blue with the McMaster Health Science Class of 2015
DrJay
#17 Posted : Sunday, May 06, 2012 7:23:22 PM
Rank: Senior Student


Joined: 5/3/2012
Posts: 93
Bowchickawowwow wrote:
Thanks for taking the time to answer questions. I was wondering if you took Orgo in the summer? Also, what 2 years in Health Sci were your highest averages?


Nope, I didn't take orgo in the summer, but I know many students who did. I think you should take orgo before the MCAT - it's the one science most students don't have much exposure to prior to university.

I got into Mac Health Sci, but I didn't actually attend the program.
TD Canada Trust Scholar 2006
University of Toronto M.D. Candidate, Class of 2013

MedHopeful.com - my blog with advice and entertainment on undergrad, scholarships and medical school.

Get Started - an introductory guide for premeds to learn about applying to medical school.

Mac Health Sci Application Guide - my advice for the McMaster Health Sciences supplementary application.

EssaySensei.ca - where I provide 1-on-1 essay help for applications to medical school, scholarships, awards and programs.
Bowchickawowwow
#18 Posted : Sunday, May 06, 2012 7:30:36 PM
Rank: Senior Student


Joined: 12/31/2010
Posts: 143
DrJay wrote:
Bowchickawowwow wrote:
Thanks for taking the time to answer questions. I was wondering if you took Orgo in the summer? Also, what 2 years in Health Sci were your highest averages?


Nope, I didn't take orgo in the summer, but I know many students who did. I think you should take orgo before the MCAT - it's the one science most students don't have much exposure to prior to university.

I got into Mac Health Sci, but I didn't actually attend the program.


Oh, what program did you attend, if you don't mind answering. What else courses do you suggest taking that would benefit me for the MCAT?
Bleeding Blue with the McMaster Health Science Class of 2015
TH3U
#19 Posted : Sunday, May 06, 2012 7:33:34 PM
Rank: Frosh


Joined: 1/15/2012
Posts: 28
is med school actually extremely hard as people claim...like will an average b student from high school have any shred of chance surviving in med school. And how hard was the mcat? Do you believe you someone who did not major in sciences but majored in psychology or something but took some science courses have chance of doing good on the mcat?
DrJay
#20 Posted : Monday, May 07, 2012 12:48:19 PM
Rank: Senior Student


Joined: 5/3/2012
Posts: 93
Bowchickawowwow wrote:
DrJay wrote:
Bowchickawowwow wrote:
Thanks for taking the time to answer questions. I was wondering if you took Orgo in the summer? Also, what 2 years in Health Sci were your highest averages?


Nope, I didn't take orgo in the summer, but I know many students who did. I think you should take orgo before the MCAT - it's the one science most students don't have much exposure to prior to university.

I got into Mac Health Sci, but I didn't actually attend the program.


Oh, what program did you attend, if you don't mind answering. What else courses do you suggest taking that would benefit me for the MCAT?


I'd rather not give details, but I went to a regular life sciences program.

For the MCAT, the most important courses to take are 1st year physics/chem/bio and organic chem. Physiology would also be very useful, but I think if you have a science background, you will understand the study materials for that OK.

TD Canada Trust Scholar 2006
University of Toronto M.D. Candidate, Class of 2013

MedHopeful.com - my blog with advice and entertainment on undergrad, scholarships and medical school.

Get Started - an introductory guide for premeds to learn about applying to medical school.

Mac Health Sci Application Guide - my advice for the McMaster Health Sciences supplementary application.

EssaySensei.ca - where I provide 1-on-1 essay help for applications to medical school, scholarships, awards and programs.
12 Pages 123>»
Forum Jump  

Powered by YAF | YAF © 2003-2013, Yet Another Forum.NET
Copyright © 2003-2013 Yet Another Forum.net. All rights reserved.
Copyright © 1998-2013 studentawards.com & boursetudes.com - Studentawards Inc. All rights reserved.